Scoutnet vzw

We connect scouts!
Het is momenteel 29 Mrt 2024 15:54

Alle tijden zijn UTC + 1 uur




Plaats een nieuw onderwerp Reageren op dit onderwerp  [ 3 berichten ] 
Auteur Bericht
BerichtGeplaatst: 06 Okt 2004 22:06 
Offline
Site Admin
Site Admin
Gebruikers-avatar

Geregistreerd: 31 Aug 2002 23:00
Berichten: 473
Woonplaats: Tongerlo
Conversations: Bit Prepared II: Richard Stallman Meets the World Scout Bureau
Posted on Thursday, October 07, 2004 by Marco Fioretti


Richard Stallman from the FSF, Ray Saunders from the World Scout Bureau
and the author discuss the connections between free software and Scouting
philosophies.

The Free Software Foundation (FSF) promotes computer users' rights to use,
modify and redistribute free (as in freedom, regardless of price) software
and documentation. All around the world, national and international
organizations exist that independently take their inspiration from the
writings of Baden-Powell, who started Scouting in 1907.

What could Baden-Powell have in common with FSF? Nothing, except a few
essential ethical principles. In "Bit Prepared, Part I, I wrote, "[GNU/]
Linux and the whole FLOSS movement do appear as the soul of Scouting made
software: the first, if not only, kind of IT technology that should to
Scouts, or used by their leaders".

After writing that article, I was contacted by the World Organization of
the Scout Movement (WOSM), an umbrella body that brings together Scout
organizations from more than 150 countries. Implementation of the WOSM
policies adopted by the World Scout Conference largely is delegated to a
professional body, the World Scout Bureau (WSB). I asked the WSB and FSF
if they would be to have representatives meet on-line to discuss my theses
and to find out if and how WOSM should use products and practices from the
free software movement in its activities.

The initial feedback from both organizations was encouraging. Richard M.
Stallman, founder of FSF, said, "[The Bit Prepared article] is very
interesting.... You may succeed in starting something very useful with
this." WOSM never had addressed itself directly to the question of
adopting particular IT policies at a world level, but according to Ray
Saunders, WSB Director, Information Technology, "the synergy between the
ideals of Scouting and the principles under-pinning the Open Source
community is indeed evident." Starting from there, I engaged Richard and
Ray in the e-mail interview that follows.

Marco Fioretti: What is free software?

Richard Stallman: Free software is software that users are free to run,
study, change and redistribute. It means that you are free to adapt it to
your needs and free to help others by sharing it. By contrast, non-free
software prohibits cooperation.

Fioretti: In the "Bit Prepared" article, I listed some affinities between
the philosophy of Scouting and that of the Free Software movement. What do
you think about them?

Stallman: That such similarities should exist does not surprise me,
because ideas of self-reliance and the importance of helping your neighbor
circulate in our society and will pop up in various places. However, I
think it was a good stroke of insight on your part to notice this
particular similarity.

Ray Saunders: I think we can all agree that the good practices evident in
the Free Software community seem to me to be entirely consistent with the
method and ideals represented in Scouting today.

Fioretti: Does the WOSM currently recommend the use of any specific
software product?

Saunders: No, for the very reasons that are stated in your introduction
above.

Fioretti: What are the criteria currently used by the World Scout Bureau
when choosing software for internal use?

Saunders: We try to select the most appropriate software according to our
needs and, of course, our means. Cost is a very important criteria for us.
When we spend money, we are spending our members money. The World Scout
Bureau primarily but not exclusively uses Apple Macintosh computers. As we
migrate to Mac OS X, the possibilities for us to use open source and free
software are now much wider than they were just a couple of years ago. As
a result, open source and free software solutions are now actively being
considered alongside the commercial products we currently use. We are
already upgrading some of the commercial software we used previously to
open source or free software alternatives. [Editors' Note: Other success
stories of Scouts using free software can be found in the comments to "Bit
Prepared" posted by Ray and Gino Lucrezi of Global Scoutnet.

Fioretti: Do the Free Software Foundation and GNU recommend the usage of
only the software they produce? If yes, why? If not, how does one choose
to adopt any software program, regardless of its origin?

Stallman: It's not who was the developer, it's whether he respects your
freedom that matters. If you want to live in freedom, you've got to reject
software that tramples your freedom. You shouldn't stand for software that
keeps you helpless or forbids helping others. When a program is free
software, that means you and others can see what it does. So you can
listen to other people in the community who have studied it and used it
and thus decide whether you want to use it. If you really are concerned
about what the program does, you can read the code yourself.

Fioretti: Many national Scout organizations have Merit Badge systems that
aim to help young members learn practical skills in a variety of
disciplines. Software and Internet already are proposed as Merit Badge
subjects in many associations. Is there any policy requesting that the
candidate must know the difference between proprietary and free software?
At least to know when and how it is right and legal to copy and
redistribute programs?

Saunders: Any such policy would be a matter for the national Scout
organization proposing the merit badge to its members. I would hope that
in the face of today's reality of pirated software, the issues surrounding
copyright and licensing would be addressed in some form within the
relevant requirements. That approach certainly would provide ample
opportunity to raise awareness about the differences to which you refer.
It also should improve knowledge about the availability of open-source and
free software solutions to the wider community.

Fioretti: Do you have any suggestions or comments regarding the merit
badge requirements list proposed in the "Bit Prepared" article?

Stallman: I think they look fine.

Saunders: There are a couple of places I might want to substitute
"discuss" with "demonstrate", but they represent a good starting point for
any national Scout organization thinking of introducing or reviewing a
computer merit badge scheme today.

Fioretti: Should a Scout association decide to try or switch to free
software or at least free formats and protocols, where can it find help
from the free software community?

Stallman: Look in http://www.gnu.org/directory for our list of over 3,500
ready-to-use free software packages that run on GNU/Linux. If you're
considering using a program that isn't in the directory,
http://www.gnu.org/licenses/license-list.html can help you judge whether a
license qualifies as free. If you live in a city, there are people in the
city who know how to use GNU/Linux. There probably is a user group there.
If you approach them asking them to help your troop switch, they probably
will be glad to help. [Editors' Note: Two on-line lists of user groups can
be found here and here.]

Fioretti: Ray, what about support from within WOSM, besides Global Scoutnet?

Saunders: I'm not aware of Scout-specific resources addressing directly
this topic. Perhaps your readers can inform me otherwise? There are a
number of software applications related to Scout activities, developed by
Scouts and made available to other Scouts to use, though not always free.
Some are listed at David Jansen's InterNETional Scouting and Guiding
Pages. The UNESCO's Free Software Portal also is a very helpful starting
point.

The Jamboree on the Internet (JOTI), an annual event during which Scouting
experiences are exchanged and ideas are shared, contributes knowledge to
the world brotherhood of Scouting. During JOTI, as many as half-a-million
Scouts from all over the world make contact with one another using the
full range of operating systems and software, much of it using open-source
software. Certainly there's the opportunity within that event for a bit
more research on these issues. This year's event runs October 16-17.

Fioretti: Will there be a specific forum devoted to these issues as part
of JOTI? If yes, could I or Richard participate to represent the free
software community?

Saunders: Not as far as I am aware this year, but it's a good suggestion
for the future. Full information about this year's events can be found by
following the links from our Web site.

Fioretti: Ray brought some interesting Scout documents to my attention.
Strategic Priority #7 of the current World Scout Strategy says, "Effective
communications are vital to all aspects of Scouting.... Modern
technologies offer Scouting many new techniques for doing this, more
effectively, more efficiently and at a lower cost". Eduardo Missoni, WOSM
Secretary General, also said in his speech at the 2004 European Scout
Conference, "According to our principles and values, we will be in the
front line in exploring and adopting open, universally accessible and
appropriate technologies". Richard, were you aware of this? What do you
think?

Stallman: One could interpret this as meaning free software, but one also
could interpret it in other weaker ways.

Fioretti: I agree, but the statements above seem to match perfectly the
recommendations I made at the end of "Bit Prepared". For example, all
Scout organizations should make sure their Web sites are viewable with any
browser and, above all, don't accept or distribute documents in
proprietary formats, as Richard suggested some time ago.

Saunders: I welcome the anybrowser.org campaign. Internationally agreed
standards should not be subsequently enhanced to commercial advantage,
which often renders the results incompatible with standards-compliant
browsers. We need to check our own sites from time to time and ensure that
we are achieving maximum accessibility for users based on the agreed
standards, not the modified versions created largely by proprietary
products and tools.

We must distinguish here between good and bad practices in the field of
proprietary formats. For example, I would describe a proprietary format
for which the proprietor provides freely available reader software (such
as Adobe does for its proprietary portable document format .pdf) as an
acceptable practice. As a result, I am happy to distribute and receive
documents in that format. My core sensitivity is that the recipient of any
item I send should not have to go out and purchase a proprietary product
in order to read my content.

Proprietary products using open standards for their file types also sit
comfortably in my portfolio of acceptable solutions. You get what you pay
for and can migrate to another product with relative ease, because the
content you have produced is not locked-in to the creative tool.

Stallman: A zero-price but secret reader program still would take the
user's freedom even if it did not take the user's money. What makes the
PDF format open--thus, not proprietary--is its documentation is public
and, aside from the newest features that mostly are not used, it is not
covered by patents, so anyone can implement it. I use free software to use
PDF files.

Fioretti: Of course, the easiest way to prepare a migration to free
software or, at least, to achieve universal accessibility is to switch as
soon as possible to free cross-platform programs, such as the
communication suite Mozilla and, above all, OASIS office file formats
through OpenOffice.org. Doing so would guarantee that every Scout always
could access Scout information, that e-mail could be signed digitally
according to standards and that Web sites could be generated for the
widest possible audience. After these steps, every single Scout or Scout
unit then would be free to decide if, when and how to make a complete
transition to free software.

Now, let's assume the WSB fully accepts this policy. Ray, may we ask you
to explain what procedure the WSB should follow to officially embrace it;
if and how it could request or suggest that the national associations do
the same; and how official practical guidelines could be provided to
facilitate its adoption?

Saunders: We like to talk about learning by doing in Scouting. So my
message to any Scout reading this is to make a personal commitment now to
get involved and try some free software for yourself, as I have done. For
example, I'm currently involved in the alpha test of NeoOffice/J, the
great Java implementation of OpenOffice.org 1.1.2 created by Patrick Luby
for us Mac OS X users. It's important that as many Scouts as possible
contribute to this process of change from a position of personal
experience. So, the first guideline might be best expressed as, "Think
globally. Act locally!"

Second, I think it will be important to ensure that the young people
attending our World Scout events encounter open source and free software
on the computers put at their disposal on those occasions. This already
has happened with success during the last World Scout Jamboree in
Thailand, for example. I remind you again that much of the annual Jamboree
on the Internet already is functioning on open-source software solutions,
so that is another area where our young members and their adult leaders
can gain practical, hands-on experience using free software.

Third, I think it is essential to be able to demonstrate that the use of
open-source software, such as OpenOffice, is a reality in the Central
Office of the World Scout Bureau. We have started providing our internal
stationery templates in OpenOffice.org format files, and a number of the
team in Geneva already have migrated to using OpenOffice.org. I'm pleased
to include Eduardo Missoni amongst those users reporting that they are
very satisfied with the experience. So, professionally, we've already
begun to play our small part in the process of creating momentum for
change.

All these successful experiences then can be used to promote the use of
free and open-source software to others, such as the leaders of national
Scout organizations and the volunteers serving on the World Scout
Committee or on our regional Scout committees.

I believe that taking practical steps, such as these I've outlined above,
will create the necessary critical mass required to bring about policy
changes inside our national member organizations that, ultimately, can
result in them collectively choosing to adopt policies to be promoted at
the world level.

Stallman: I have to point out that to contrast free software with
commercial software is like contrasting tall people with thin people. Some
free software is commercial (developed by businesses), just as some tall
people are thin. Copies of free software often are sold for a price;
meanwhile, some non-free programs are available gratis.

The issue is not about business and not about price--it's about freedom.
Free software respects the user's freedom; non-free software does not. If
a program is free, you can "leave it better than you found it" if you so
wish, and that's where free software meets the spirit of Scouting.

When choosing any given program, I suggest you verify that it is free
software and that it can run on a free platform. MacOS is not free and
neither is the usual Java platform. So, if NeoOffice/J depends on them, it
cannot be used without limiting your freedom.

Saunders: Using enabling technologies in the short term that allow many
more people to try out free or open-source software now may be limiting,
in Richard's view, but if it helps more people get on the bus and take a
tour for themselves, that should be to the benefit of an organization such
as FSF, as awareness and support for free (as in freedom) software grows.
And that, I believe, is in everyone's best interests.

Fioretti: I am glad to hear all this for two reasons. The first is, from
now on, it will be hard for any Scout to ignore the ideals of free
software and the importance of communicating through truly open
technologies. The second reason is the approach described by Ray makes it
possible for single Scouts or Scouts units to migrate to free software if
and when they choose, in the smoothest possible way.

I therefore conclude this interview with four short invitations. The first
is to all Scouts: please try the software Ray and Richard mention and
contact the closest GNU/Linux user group for help. The second is to all
supporters of free software, starting with OpenOffice.org and Mozilla:
send this article and "Bit Prepared" Part I or bring it by hand to the
closest Scout group and offer your help to try free software. Next, to
make all this easier, everybody who can translate both articles in other
languages, please mfioretti@mclink.it contact me. Last but not least, any
other organization inspired by Baden-Powell is welcome to contact me; I am
eager to know what you think of free software.

Thanks to Richard and Ray for their time.

source: http://www.linuxjournal.com/article.php ... ad&order=0


Omhoog
 Profiel  
 
 Titel:
BerichtGeplaatst: 08 Okt 2004 13:27 
Offline
 
 
Gebruikers-avatar

Geregistreerd: 22 Jan 2004 0:00
Berichten: 773
GNU al goed en wel, maar RMS is wel een beetje een hele rare kwiet hoor :) Twee jaar geleden op den unief naar een lezing geweest van hem... De decaan begon zich serieus af te vragen waar hij in godsnaam dat geld voor uitgegeven had :p


Omhoog
 Profiel  
 
 Titel:
BerichtGeplaatst: 08 Okt 2004 20:18 
Offline
 
 
Gebruikers-avatar

Geregistreerd: 20 Sep 2002 23:00
Berichten: 166
RMS vraagt niet veel geld hoor voor een toespraak. RMS komt elk jaar naar FOSDEM en tijdens die periode doet hij overal wel een lezing. Zolang er genoeg volk in de zaal zit en er thee is, is hij tevreden.


Omhoog
 Profiel  
 
Berichten weergeven van de afgelopen:  Sorteer op  
Plaats een nieuw onderwerp Reageren op dit onderwerp  [ 3 berichten ] 

Alle tijden zijn UTC + 1 uur


Wie is er online?

Gebruikers in dit forum: Geen geregistreerde gebruikers en 12 gasten


U mag geen nieuwe onderwerpen plaatsen in dit forum
U mag geen reacties plaatsen op onderwerpen in dit forum
U mag uw berichten niet wijzigen in dit forum
U mag uw berichten niet verwijderen in dit forum
U mag geen bijlagen plaatsen in dit forum

Zoeken naar:
Ga naar:  
cron
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
Vertaald door phpBBservice.nl.